AG says social network access isn't free if you pay with your data

Published: 19/11/2026
| CJEU

Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) Advocate General (AG) Laila Medina has issued an Opinion in Case C-643/25 proposing that digital services cannot be described as "free" under EU consumer protection law when users must provide personal data and consent to its commercial exploitation in exchange for access.

The case stems from a challenge by the German Federal Union of Consumer Organisations and Associations against Meta over a February 2015 Facebook registration page stating that "Facebook is and remains free". While lower German courts dismissed the claim on the grounds that such prohibitions apply only to monetary costs, the Federal Court of Justice referred the dispute to the CJEU.

AG Medina concluded that disclosing personal data for commercial use constitutes a form of payment under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (UCPD), because such data carries economic value that enables operators to generate advertising revenue and finance their services. Consequently, describing a service as "free" is prohibited in all circumstances unless data is processed exclusively to provide the service or meet legal obligations.

In rejecting Meta's arguments, Medina clarified that the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) does not preclude the application of the UCPD. While the GDPR regulates the lawful and transparent processing of personal data, the UCPD governs the accuracy of commercial claims, meaning both frameworks apply cumulatively. Medina added that this interpretation does not restrict the freedom to conduct business, as companies remain free to offer services in exchange for personal data provided they do not market them as "free".


Training Announcement: Freevacy offers a range of independent data protection qualifications from IAPP and BCS. Our certified courses are available at foundation and practitioner levels and cover multiple legal jurisdictions, data protection operations management, and the implementation of complex privacy solutions in technical environments. Find out more.

Read Full Story
Paid or free, Pay or OK, tiered subscription model, Consent or Pay

What is this page?

You are reading a summary article on the Privacy Newsfeed, a free resource for DPOs and other professionals with privacy or data protection responsibilities helping them stay informed of industry news all in one place. The information here is a brief snippet relating to a single piece of original content or several articles about a common topic or thread. The main contributor is listed in the top left-hand corner, just beneath the article title.

The Privacy Newsfeed monitors over 300 global publications, of which more than 3,250 summary articles have been posted to the online archive dating back to the beginning of 2020. A weekly roundup is available by email every Friday.